Annie's wins. The first taste had us searching for the tomatoes. The blandest on the list has no tomato flavor.
Safeway's Signature Select tomato soup looked odd at first. Before adding water, this soup resembled ketchup.
Amy's organic tomato soup was delicious. The thick, creamy texture delivered, but the flavor left us wanting more.
Pacific Foods' organic roasted red pepper and tomato soup boldly entered our list. We smelled peppers as we opened that can.
Progresso's tomato soup takes the "middle-of-the-road" award. It looks like excellent tomato soup—thick and crimson.
Great Value's tomato soup is sweet with a salty finish that completes the flavor journey.
Market Basket's tomato soup also surprised. The can's ketchup-like consistency made us worried, but the taste isn't like French fry sauce.
Imagine Organic Tomato Basil Creamy Soup surprised us with its delicious flavor, placing fourth on our list.
Imagine Organic Tomato Basil Creamy Soup surprised us with its delicious flavor, placing fourth on our list.
Trader Joe's Organic Creamy Tomato Soup steals the scene. The first bite will transport you to an artisan bakery with robust tastes.